Week 34: SUPREME COURT ALERT: Taser Use in Schools Under Review

Welcome To The Street
"Empowering Modern Policing, Inspiring the Future."

Good Morning ! It’s Monday, September 16, and this week we’re covering De-escalation techniques, the latest law enforcement news, and a case that you should be keeping an eye on. First time reading? Join law enforcement nationwidesign up here.

Your feedback is vital to us, so don’t forget to share your thoughts. If you find this briefing valuable, forward it to a friend or your entire shift 🫣

🗓️ WHAT TO EXPECT

🔥 PRIORITY BRIEFING
Case Law Spotlight: Taser Use In Schools

The Supreme Court may soon review J. W. v. Paley, a case that could redefine how school resource officers (SROs) use force. This case involves Officer Elvin Paley and his use of a Taser on Jevon Washington, a 17-year-old student with intellectual disabilities. Key points:

Key Issue: Fourth vs. Fourteenth Amendment

  • Question: Should the Fourth Amendment's excessive force standard apply, or should the Fourteenth Amendment's due process standard govern SRO actions in schools?

  • Why It Matters:
    If the Fourth Amendment standard is applied, officers' actions in schools may be judged similarly to encounters on the streets, emphasizing reasonableness in the moment. Conversely, the Fourteenth Amendment standard, which involves a higher threshold for proving a violation, could lead to fewer restrictions on force in educational settings.

Lower Court Ruling

  • Outcome: Claims were dismissed based on qualified immunity and due process.

  • Implication: The ruling suggests that qualified immunity can shield officers, but it also underscores the importance of reasonable use of force.

Petition Argument

  • Claim: The Fourth Amendment standard is better suited for assessing SRO actions involving students.

  • Potential Change: If accepted, this could lead to stricter evaluations of force used by SROs and emphasize de-escalation techniques.

What to Watch

  • Potential Impact: A Supreme Court ruling could lead to new national standards for force in schools, affecting SRO training and policy.

  • Action for Officers: Prepare for possible changes by enhancing de-escalation skills and understanding how new standards may impact daily practices.

Practical Tips for SROs

  1. Adapt Your Tactics: Use force cautiously, especially with vulnerable students. Prioritize de-escalation and alternative methods.

  2. Focus on Training: Ensure regular training on de-escalation and proportionality in school settings.

  3. Stay Informed: Watch for updates on this case to align your practices with evolving legal standards.

 NEWS
 The Latest News in Policing

  • 👮🏽‍♂️💔 Florida Officer Dies After Falling Ill During Field Force Team Tryout

  • 💰⏳ San Diego County Sheriff's Office Halts Mandatory Overtime After $94 Million Spent Last Fiscal Year. Read Here

  • 📉🚔 Lancaster, PA Cuts Officer Positions from 145 to 128, with 20 Vacancies Still Unfilled. Read More

  • 🇺🇸🤝 Former President Trump Secures Major Police Union Endorsement, Addresses Migrant Crime. Find out more.

  • ⚖️📂 LAPD Officers File Complaints Over City’s Move to Dismiss Lawsuits Stemming from 2022 Undercover Officer Info Leak. More

 OFFICER DOWN: THIS WEEK’S FALLEN HEROES
 Weekly Line of Duty Deaths: 2

Fallen Heroes

Deputy: Jeremy Boykins
Department: West Palm Beach Police Department, Florida
End of Watch: Tuesday, September 10th, 2024
Incident: Medical
🔗 Read Incident Details Here

Corporal: Brendon Schreiber
Department: Newton County Sheriff’s Office, Indiana
End of Watch: Wednesday, September 11, 2024
Incident: Gunfire
🔗 Read Incident Details Here

De-escalation Tactics: A Street-Level Approach for Officers

In the unpredictable field of law enforcement, mastering de-escalation is not just about diffusing tense situations; it's about controlling the flow of interaction, protecting lives, and fostering trust in the community. Below are practical, field-tested de-escalation techniques that can help officers handle high-stress encounters with finesse and focus:

🚨 1. Tactical Pauses: The Power of Creating Time and Space

Slowing down a volatile situation gives officers time to assess and act more strategically. The aim is to avoid knee-jerk reactions, giving both the officer and the subject a moment to recalibrate.

  • Tactical repositioning: Use natural barriers (cars, buildings, etc.) to maintain cover and increase your distance. It buys time and prevents escalation.

  • Control the approach: Move methodically. Rapid movements can trigger flight or fight responses.

  • Silence as a tool: In high-tension situations, silence can often de-escalate more effectively than words, allowing the subject to vent while you stay composed.

🗣️ 2. Advanced Communication: Words That Lead to Cooperation

Effective communication is more than just talking. It’s about leading the conversation toward a peaceful resolution by controlling tone, body language, and verbal cues.

  • Use 'you' statements sparingly: Instead of "You need to calm down," try "I want to help you, but we need to slow down." It personalizes the conversation without triggering defensiveness.

  • Tactical paraphrasing: Repeat what the subject is saying to show you're listening. “I hear that you're upset because…” This validates their feelings and can often de-escalate without further action.

  • Intentional body language: Standing at a slight angle and keeping your hands visible can reduce perceived threat levels.

😌 3. Reading Emotional Cues: The Power of Psychological First Aid

Understanding a subject’s emotional state is critical. Officers should aim to read between the lines, recognizing that what’s being said may not be the whole picture.

  • Match their emotional intensity: If someone is visibly agitated, speaking in a completely calm voice might feel condescending. Instead, acknowledge their energy level, then gradually slow your pace to bring them down.

  • Mirror their posture and movements: Subtle mirroring (without mocking) can build rapport and make the subject feel understood.

  • Engage in empathy under pressure: Acknowledging frustration with phrases like “I can see you’re frustrated, and I’m here to help,” can often defuse a confrontational situation.

✋ 4. Strategic Choices: Empowerment Leads to Compliance

Offering choices in a controlled situation gives the subject a sense of control, which can reduce their perceived need to resist.

  • Present options with outcomes: Instead of "Do this or else," try “We have two paths: If you do [this], we can resolve things calmly. If not, the outcome might be more difficult.”

  • Positive reinforcement for compliance: Acknowledge even small cooperative gestures. "Thanks for lowering your voice, I appreciate that."

  • Guide, don’t order: Use guiding language such as “Let’s walk over here together” instead of direct commands, making cooperation feel like a joint decision.

💡 5. Emotional Management: Rational Detachment and Self-Control

Officers are human, and emotions can run high in confrontational situations. Rational detachment—the ability to control one’s emotional response—ensures that officers remain in command of their actions.

  • Use pre-prepared mantras: Repeat phrases like “My goal is control, not confrontation,” or “I am here to resolve, not react” when tensions rise.

  • Engage the breathing technique: In the moment, take a few controlled breaths before engaging. This not only calms you but models behavior for the subject to mirror.

  • Recognize personal triggers: Every officer has situations that get under their skin. Knowing yours in advance allows you to recognize when it's time to ask for a colleague’s assistance.

🛡️ 6. Team Tactics: The Value of Coordinated De-escalation

When officers work together in high-pressure scenarios, a coordinated approach can often prevent things from spiraling.

  • Designate roles: One officer communicates while others manage containment. Avoid multiple officers giving conflicting commands.

  • Use the 'Contact and Cover' method: One officer speaks directly while others monitor and ensure officer safety. This reduces confusion for the subject and ensures clarity in communication.

  • Tag team emotional dynamics: If one officer feels they are getting emotionally involved, they should rotate out and allow a colleague to take over the lead.

📈 7. Commit to Continuous Improvement: Evolving with Training and Practice

De-escalation isn’t a one-time training event—it’s an evolving skill that requires constant refinement.

  • Utilize scenario-based training: Virtual reality simulations and role-playing scenarios that mimic real-life de-escalation situations will sharpen skills and make responses second nature.

  • Field debriefs: After a high-tension situation, debrief with your team on what worked and what didn’t. This critical reflection allows growth and fosters better responses in future situations.

By taking these practical, street-proven techniques and integrating them into your daily routines, you’ll not only sharpen your de-escalation skills but also contribute to a safer, more professional police culture. Remember, effective de-escalation is about consistent practice, emotional control, and strategic communication. It’s not just about solving the moment—it’s about protecting lives and building trust.

If you enjoyed the newsletter leave us some feedback below and Forward This Email to Other Officer’s.

How did we do?

Leave us some feedback so we can continue to improve.

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Reply

or to participate.